Guardianship vs. Power of Attorney: Which One Should You Choose?

When planning for your own future or a loved one's, two legal tools often come up: guardianship and a power of attorney. They might seem similar (in a way, they are, both give someone the authority to make decisions for another), but they work in very different ways, have different ranges, and involve vastly different levels of court control. It’s important to differentiate the two to save your money and time later on. 

Here’s the key takeaway:

Power of Attorney:

Gives you the power to let someone you choose handle financial, legal, or healthcare decisions for you while you’re still alive. It is created proactively, doesn’t require court intervention, and can be completely customized to specific needs.

Guardianship:

A legal status granted by a court, giving someone authority to make decisions for another person who cannot manage their own affairs. It is reactive, often arises after someone becomes incapacitated, and requires ongoing court oversight.

Knowing the difference and when to use each can help you protect your assets, ensure your loved ones are cared for, and maintain as much independence as possible.

Expanding Into The Roles of a Power of Attorney

A power of attorney is a legal document in which you (the “principal”) appoint someone you trust (the “agent” or “attorney-in-fact”) to make decisions on your behalf. Powers of attorney can be financial, medical, or general, depending on the powers you grant.

Powers of attorney are made to plan for the future, voluntarily—you create them while you still can. You decide exactly which powers the agent has. For instance, a financial power of attorney might allow paying bills and managing investments, but not selling real estate. Powers of attorney are revocable at any time as long as you are competent, and they generally avoid court involvement unless a dispute arises.

Example: Imagine Susan wants her adult daughter, Emma, to manage her financial affairs if she becomes ill. Susan signs a financial power of attorney specifying that Emma can pay bills, manage her bank accounts, and handle tax filings. Later, Susan develops temporary incapacity from surgery and needs to recover properly. Emma can step in immediately without going to court, keeping Susan’s finances in order.

Expanding Into the Roles of a Power of Attorney

Guardianship is a court-appointed relationship where one person (the guardian) is given legal authority to make decisions for another (the ward) who has been determined to be unable to manage personal, medical, or financial matters. Guardianship usually arises after incapacity and involves ongoing oversight by a court.

Guardianship is reactive and formal. The court evaluates the individual’s capacity, appoints a guardian it sees fit, and requires regular reporting. Guardians often have broad authority over both personal and financial decisions, though the court may limit powers depending on the situation.

Example: John, an elderly man, suffers a severe stroke and is unable to manage his daily care or finances. His adult son petitions the court for guardianship. The judge evaluates John’s capacity, appoints the son as his guardian, and requires quarterly reports to ensure John’s needs are met. The son now has the authority to make medical decisions, manage bank accounts, and handle housing arrangements.

How Do Powers of Attorney and Guardianship Differ? 

A power of attorney is created voluntarily by the principal and can be tailored to specific tasks, while guardianship is established by a court only after someone becomes incapacitated. Powers of attorney require minimal court involvement and can be revoked at any time while the principal is competent, whereas guardianships involve ongoing court supervision and court oversight.

When to Use a Power of Attorney

A power of attorney is ideal for anyone who wants to plan ahead for potential incapacity. Situations where a power of attorney is useful include:

• Managing finances during extended illness

• Handling intricate investments or tax filings

• Making medical decisions if you’re temporarily incapacitated

• Authorizing someone to sign documents when you’re unavailable

  
  

Pro Tips:

• Choose an agent you trust completely, as they will have access to personal information and potentially hold broad power over your life.

• Specify the range your agent has clearly. You can grant broad powers or limit them to specific accounts or types of decisions.

• Keep the document updated as life circumstances change, such as the death of an agent, new financial accounts, or changes in health.

When Guardianship Becomes Necessary

Guardianship is generally pursued when someone can no longer make safe, informed decisions. Common scenarios include:

• Severe cognitive impairment, such as dementia that has advanced or a major stroke

• Disagreements among family members about care arrangements

• No existing power of attorney, or the designated agent is unable or unwilling to act

  
  

Guardianship should be considered a last resort because it is invasive, costly, and involves ongoing court oversight. Here in Georgia, the court will evaluate the individual’s capacity, consider less restrictive alternatives, and appoint a guardian only when necessary.

How Powers of Attorney and Guardianship Can Work Together

Sometimes, both tools are needed. A parent might create a durable financial power of attorney while still healthy, giving an agent authority to manage day-to-day finances. If the parent later becomes severely incapacitated and the power of attorney doesn’t cover certain long-term decisions—or the agent cannot act—the family may petition the court for guardianship to fill the gaps.

Let’s put it into an example: Maria had a financial and healthcare power of attorney naming her son, Luis. When Maria suffered a stroke, Luis could immediately handle bills and medical consent. Later, when Maria developed advanced Alzheimer’s and could no longer manage day-to-day affairs, the court appointed her son as guardian to make long-term housing and care decisions. Maria’s early power of attorney made the transition smoother, legally and emotionally. 

Tips for Families in Georgia

1. Start early – Don’t wait for a health crisis to create a power of attorney. It’s much easier to create one now than to wait for the court to appoint a guardian later on.

2. Document everything – Keep powers of attorney, wills, and medical directives organized and accessible.

3. Review regularly – Be sure to update powers of attorney if agents change, finances differ, or family dynamics vary.

4. Get an Estate Planning Attorney – Georgia laws about powers of attorney, healthcare consent, and guardianship can be complex to the everyday person. Having legal advice from an attorney helps more than you’d imagine in ensuring your documents are valid and enforceable. Attorneys help you handle and understand the legal jargon while giving you insights on how to move forward.

Moving Forward

By planning ahead, communicating openly with family members, and consulting legal professionals, you can create a system that protects your finances, healthcare, and personal wishes. The right preparation today can make a difficult situation far more manageable tomorrow. We hope this article was of use to you. If you have further questions, feel free to reach out to us for more information.

Ask a question